How do you track your productivity?
Original Post
Do you track your productivity both at home and work? If both, do you use the same metric towards productivity? I'm presently measuring both, and will probably use the same metric for each but am considering all of the options.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
I don't. I don't know any good measurements of productivity neither.
Reply by Avrum
Here's what I'm trying:
Purpose: To measure how often I'm using DWM (and what I'm doing) throughout the week
Tool: QuickLog http://quicklog.polygon-house.com/
Whenever I'm working off my DWM list (via The Hit List), I monitor my work with QuickLog. QuickLog syncs with Google Calendar. This provides a graphical overview of how you spent your day/week.
Purpose: To measure how often I'm using DWM (and what I'm doing) throughout the week
Tool: QuickLog http://quicklog.polygon-house.com/
Whenever I'm working off my DWM list (via The Hit List), I monitor my work with QuickLog. QuickLog syncs with Google Calendar. This provides a graphical overview of how you spent your day/week.
Reply by Erik
I don't either...
I know it will sound like I'm full of myself but I believe productivity is an illusion.
I do have a kind of metric and it's the Pomodoro.
This said, may I ask: Why be Productive when you can be Effective?
Measuring effectiveness seems (to me at least) much healthier for the soul and the stress system...
I know it will sound like I'm full of myself but I believe productivity is an illusion.
I do have a kind of metric and it's the Pomodoro.
This said, may I ask: Why be Productive when you can be Effective?
Measuring effectiveness seems (to me at least) much healthier for the soul and the stress system...
Reply by Gerry
I find it hard to track as well. Some days I get many tasks done, but they are of low value, other days I only do a few things, but they ring the register so they are more important. so in essence, it is by feel. Do I feel a particular day was productive.
Gerry
Gerry
Reply by TK
I think we might be tripping over semantics a bit. The way I measure my productivity is to work in timed, 30 minute blocks. I see how many of these blocks I can complete in a day. For a productivity or efficiency rating, I divide the number of hours of productivity by the number of hours worked.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
But that's a measure of endurance, not productivity. Me if I work too hard at something I get tired and slow down. I end up being less productive than otherwise. See also the proverb about stopping to sharpen the saw.
I think all productivity measures are task specific. If you are sharpening pencils you can count the sharp pencils. Time is like boxes. It contains activities. It's not important how many boxes have stuff. What's important is the amount of quality stuff you have at the end.
I think all productivity measures are task specific. If you are sharpening pencils you can count the sharp pencils. Time is like boxes. It contains activities. It's not important how many boxes have stuff. What's important is the amount of quality stuff you have at the end.
Reply by Leon
I just measure whether I have got upto date with my incomings emails voicemails and paperwork. I use the Do It programme (3 desired Outcomes) and one evaluates progress on this daily.
I found timed bursts / pomodoros effective as a focusing tool yet a blunt instrument at times for any sort of measurement of productivity. One short telephone conversation could unlock a mojor project yet it might not even make it into a timed session.
I found timed bursts / pomodoros effective as a focusing tool yet a blunt instrument at times for any sort of measurement of productivity. One short telephone conversation could unlock a mojor project yet it might not even make it into a timed session.
Reply by Avrum
For more on (and how) people track:
http://www.quantifiedself.com/
"Some days I get many tasks done, but they are of low value, other days I only do a few things"
I feel the same way. However even if all my activity is low value - while using Mark's, or any system - there's some mindful aspect via tracking. Moreover, I do far, far less low value things (read: facebook) while tracking.
QuickLog syncs to Google Calendar, providing me with a weekly snapshot of where my DWM time went. I find that helpful (and motivating).
http://www.quantifiedself.com/
"Some days I get many tasks done, but they are of low value, other days I only do a few things"
I feel the same way. However even if all my activity is low value - while using Mark's, or any system - there's some mindful aspect via tracking. Moreover, I do far, far less low value things (read: facebook) while tracking.
QuickLog syncs to Google Calendar, providing me with a weekly snapshot of where my DWM time went. I find that helpful (and motivating).
Reply by Sarah
I don't really track how much I'm getting done in any systematic way. For me, it's pretty evident... am I making progress on my various projects? Am I ready for class at the moment I find myself standing in the room in front of 30 half-asleep college students? How many things are getting dismissed? I did just start archiving my dismissed items (I use DWM) into their own folder on Toodledo (I have one for "active" and one for "dismissed") so that I have some sense of what's going over the Falls and can look for patterns therein should I want/ need to.
For a while, before I found AF, I used slife (http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/productivity_tools/slife.html) but it was buggy as all get out at the time. I might give it another go, actually, just for curiosity's sake.
For a while, before I found AF, I used slife (http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/productivity_tools/slife.html) but it was buggy as all get out at the time. I might give it another go, actually, just for curiosity's sake.
Reply by Barak
I used to work at the US Department of Labor in Seattle, mainly on projects to encourage a culture shift in state and local agencies towards quality, customer satisfaction and continuous learning.
I was the resident troublemaker and oddball thinker in an office full of very talented but fairly linear thinkers.
And some of them would wonder to my teammates if I actually did anything. Because most of the time it didn't look like I was sitting at my desk focusing.
And I'd wonder about it as well.
One day when I was feeling particularly guilty, and suspecting that I was wasting the taxpayers' money, I asked myself a very different question:
"If I hadn't been here the past six month, what would be different? What wouldn't be here"
It was long enough ago that I don't remember the details of what difference I'd made. But as soon as I saw it in that light, I started to think that I needed a raise. The value I added was quite dramatic, and when I look at my experience there I can say happily that Uncle Sam got a deal.
So these are my questions when I'm wondering if I'm being effective, productive or just slacking:
1. In the last six (three, twelve, two) months (days, weeks, years) where have I come and what has changed?
2. If I hadn't been here, what would be different and what wouldn't have happened.
The trick, of course, is learning to self-regulate how you work and live. Do you focus on what's meaningful? Are you happy and enjoying life? And do you have patterns and structures and rhythms that support you in being able to get stuff done easily. If you can answer a resounding 'Yes!' to all three, you're good.
And it's always a great exploration to elevate all three of these to the next level.
Great question you posted TK, really got me thinking, thank you!!!
I was the resident troublemaker and oddball thinker in an office full of very talented but fairly linear thinkers.
And some of them would wonder to my teammates if I actually did anything. Because most of the time it didn't look like I was sitting at my desk focusing.
And I'd wonder about it as well.
One day when I was feeling particularly guilty, and suspecting that I was wasting the taxpayers' money, I asked myself a very different question:
"If I hadn't been here the past six month, what would be different? What wouldn't be here"
It was long enough ago that I don't remember the details of what difference I'd made. But as soon as I saw it in that light, I started to think that I needed a raise. The value I added was quite dramatic, and when I look at my experience there I can say happily that Uncle Sam got a deal.
So these are my questions when I'm wondering if I'm being effective, productive or just slacking:
1. In the last six (three, twelve, two) months (days, weeks, years) where have I come and what has changed?
2. If I hadn't been here, what would be different and what wouldn't have happened.
The trick, of course, is learning to self-regulate how you work and live. Do you focus on what's meaningful? Are you happy and enjoying life? And do you have patterns and structures and rhythms that support you in being able to get stuff done easily. If you can answer a resounding 'Yes!' to all three, you're good.
And it's always a great exploration to elevate all three of these to the next level.
Great question you posted TK, really got me thinking, thank you!!!
Reply by Alan Baljeu
+1. I'm stickying that, Barak!
Reply by Barak
Awesome Alan! And I saw yesterday that you left some nice words about a reply I left a couple of months ago--thank you for those as well.
Reply by Avrum
Of analyzing your own dreams, Marie-Louise von Franz used to say: "You don't analyze your own dreams because you can't see your own ass".
I would say the same is, mostly true, for our ability to answer the above questions without accountability to someone or software.
I would say the same is, mostly true, for our ability to answer the above questions without accountability to someone or software.
Reply by Erik
I conquer with Barak 100% and must add that this topic really inspired some great posts.
As for being too much in semantics...
I truly think that we are in an age of knowledge workers.
That means that our jobs are not as defined as they where.
Therefore defining if we where productive or effective is more difficult because we cannot foresee the effects as easily as say: "Planted crops so next harvest will be good!"
That's why Barak is on the money on looking BACK at what happened...
A few years back, people started to understand that there was a difference between being busy and being productive. Now the question of "is this productivity actually toward a meaningful goal?" raised it's head and all sorts of other concepts like Effectiveness and Efficiency got thrown in the mix.
I believe that being aware of those discrepancies in meaning and what you wish to focus on is quite important and not as well communicated as we might think. People talk in business of tactics when they are actually talking about strategies and vice-versa. And sometimes goals get thrown into the mix...
Heres a nice read about productivity and effectiveness:
http://personalkanban.com/expert/am-i-productive-efficient-or-effective/
As for being too much in semantics...
I truly think that we are in an age of knowledge workers.
That means that our jobs are not as defined as they where.
Therefore defining if we where productive or effective is more difficult because we cannot foresee the effects as easily as say: "Planted crops so next harvest will be good!"
That's why Barak is on the money on looking BACK at what happened...
A few years back, people started to understand that there was a difference between being busy and being productive. Now the question of "is this productivity actually toward a meaningful goal?" raised it's head and all sorts of other concepts like Effectiveness and Efficiency got thrown in the mix.
I believe that being aware of those discrepancies in meaning and what you wish to focus on is quite important and not as well communicated as we might think. People talk in business of tactics when they are actually talking about strategies and vice-versa. And sometimes goals get thrown into the mix...
Heres a nice read about productivity and effectiveness:
http://personalkanban.com/expert/am-i-productive-efficient-or-effective/
Reply by Cricket
I like the question: If I hadn't been here for ....
I sometimes give my days a letter grade, like in school, but it's against how much progress I feel I made rather than an objective standard. If I'm sick and still manage to do the minimum daily work, that's an A. If I had a productive week and intentionally take Friday off, that's also an A. I also look at why I didn't give myself a good mark. Was I avoiding tackling a project? If so, should I work on other things or subdivide the project? Do I always skip the same task? I'm thinking of dividing days into smaller parts, say morning, afternoon, after-school and evening, to see patterns there.
I sometimes give my days a letter grade, like in school, but it's against how much progress I feel I made rather than an objective standard. If I'm sick and still manage to do the minimum daily work, that's an A. If I had a productive week and intentionally take Friday off, that's also an A. I also look at why I didn't give myself a good mark. Was I avoiding tackling a project? If so, should I work on other things or subdivide the project? Do I always skip the same task? I'm thinking of dividing days into smaller parts, say morning, afternoon, after-school and evening, to see patterns there.
Reply by vegheadjones
performance metrics for myself (and probably for other knowledge workers reading this) really don't make much sense But I do keep track of three metrics that calculate automatically from my DWM/AF spreadsheet. I like to look at these three on a daily basis.
#1 % complete-- Tasks on list complete/total list.
#2 net gain/lost-- Number of tasks added and not completed today-- if it is a negative number I am closing out more tasks than I am adding.
#3 "Real tasks" done. The number of really significant tasks (usually work projects) that I completed and did not reenter.
Again, these are really silly numbers in the grand scheme of things. But I do think playing against yesterday's score on each three metrics help to motivate me to stay on list.
#1 % complete-- Tasks on list complete/total list.
#2 net gain/lost-- Number of tasks added and not completed today-- if it is a negative number I am closing out more tasks than I am adding.
#3 "Real tasks" done. The number of really significant tasks (usually work projects) that I completed and did not reenter.
Again, these are really silly numbers in the grand scheme of things. But I do think playing against yesterday's score on each three metrics help to motivate me to stay on list.
Reply by TK
Great posts-thanks everyone. Your posts have caused me to look at productivity in a lot of different ways that I wouldn't have without this forum.
TK
TK
Reply by Cricket
Metrics can help in the same way Seinfeld's "Don't Break the Chain" approach works. You pick a task that would benefit from daily work. In his case that was writing. Every day you work on it you put a dot on the calendar. Join dots on consecutive days into a chain. Eventually the urge to continue the chain helps keep you motivated.
We drive by a factory every few months. They have big signs showing accident-free days for both road and plant. Our family cheers every time we see the numbers go up, and we have nothing invested.
We drive by a factory every few months. They have big signs showing accident-free days for both road and plant. Our family cheers every time we see the numbers go up, and we have nothing invested.
Reply by Paul B
From wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_work_productivity :
"Knowledge work can ultimately be judged on whether or not three things occur [3]:
1) when something successful that never existed previously, is now up and running;
2) when something successful that existed previously has been improved or expanded; or
3) when something unsuccessful that existed previously has been stopped.
The productivity for achieving one of these things, he argued, could be judged based on the speed with which it is accomplished, and the cost required to finish the job."
I guess speed in this case would be the interval of time that it took to do and cost in our context would be related to the amount of time spent.
Not sure how this ties in with AF since I use AF to do do (1) and (2) above - but I also use AF to pursue areas of interest (reading, exploration) that are not really "productive" but they are enjoyable for me.
"Knowledge work can ultimately be judged on whether or not three things occur [3]:
1) when something successful that never existed previously, is now up and running;
2) when something successful that existed previously has been improved or expanded; or
3) when something unsuccessful that existed previously has been stopped.
The productivity for achieving one of these things, he argued, could be judged based on the speed with which it is accomplished, and the cost required to finish the job."
I guess speed in this case would be the interval of time that it took to do and cost in our context would be related to the amount of time spent.
Not sure how this ties in with AF since I use AF to do do (1) and (2) above - but I also use AF to pursue areas of interest (reading, exploration) that are not really "productive" but they are enjoyable for me.
Reply by Cricket
AF works for (3) as well. Sometimes stopping something unsuccessful involves researching the intended purpose and how to fulfill it in a better way, as well as dismantling the old system.
Reply by Erik
In regards to Paul B's post.
I really like when in the end you say that to peruse areas of interest like reading or exploration is not strictly "productive" and I believe you are right but these things ARE useful and meaningful. Theynare very effective in your life!
I really like when in the end you say that to peruse areas of interest like reading or exploration is not strictly "productive" and I believe you are right but these things ARE useful and meaningful. Theynare very effective in your life!
Reply by Seraphim
Erik wrote:
<<>>
Erik, what are your methods for measuring effectiveness?
Maybe the "feel good" metric could be useful for overall effectiveness.
http://www.markforster.net/blog/2006/9/17/feeling-good.html
But I have a feeling this is like a "conscience" metric. Sometimes our conscience needs to be "trained". Maybe we feel good but we just don't notice how we are "effective" in our own eyes but causing all our co-workers a lot of headaches. Or alternately, we are really making a great contribution but feel terrible about it for one reason or another.
Erik, also, in addition to the measure of overall effectiveness, do you have any metrics to measure the effectiveness of your _process_?
<<
Erik, what are your methods for measuring effectiveness?
Maybe the "feel good" metric could be useful for overall effectiveness.
http://www.markforster.net/blog/2006/9/17/feeling-good.html
But I have a feeling this is like a "conscience" metric. Sometimes our conscience needs to be "trained". Maybe we feel good but we just don't notice how we are "effective" in our own eyes but causing all our co-workers a lot of headaches. Or alternately, we are really making a great contribution but feel terrible about it for one reason or another.
Erik, also, in addition to the measure of overall effectiveness, do you have any metrics to measure the effectiveness of your _process_?
Reply by Erik
@ Seraphim
Wow, this is a good question!
It had me thinking for about half an hour (which means it has a lot of value for me because it will be effective in furthering my understanding of myself and my system). But still, I'm writing this as I think so I hope you will excuse the lack of conciseness and the length of it. From the bat, I must say that I don't believe that there are "metrics" easily applicable but there are ways to ensure good effectiveness in what you do.
First, I think that effectiveness is directly related to value. If you gain a lot of value from one activity compared to another, then it is more effective for you. The problem is, the type of value is quite different from task to task and from person to person. But there is 2 built in processes in my system that assure that I do the things that have the most value.
One of those is that I limit. I simply limit the amount that I'm willing to do in a day. Let me give you an example and explain the concept. If I give you 10 different cakes (and let's assume you like cake) as choices for desert but you can only choose one. You will, without fail, take the one that will give you the most enjoyment.
On top of that, that value is compared with all the other things you didn't eat. So the idea that value is also derived from the comparison with another thing comes into play. Therefore I always have a couple of choices in my system to make me choose, hence derive value for each thing and pick the one that has the most and I can only do that. All of Mark's systems have this stamp too!
If you doubt the power of limiting yourself, try Twitter. It's a wonderful tool to learn to write concisely and with value. You only have 140 characters to send your thoughts or a message. So I usually start by typing what I want to say and then cut, rephrase, restructure and change the grammar of the text to fit snuggly in those limits.
Ex:
Everybody should go watch the A-Team movie; it's a "must see"!!!
it was so hilarious... I really laughed when the guy tries to jump-start the ambulance with the defibrillator!
Would become something like:
I found "The A-Team" movie hilarious; it's a Must-See...
Watch for the guy trying to jump-start an ambulance with a defibrillator!!!
By the way, my backlog too has a limit so if I want to put something in, I have to do something or throw something out! And if I only have 30 minutes for my emails this day, I will find the most effective way to do them quite fast.
Then, I have most activities divided into categories where I can not only know what type of mindset and energy I'm going to use but also which value I'm shooting for in those activities:
Rest/Relax: Did I spend time really focussing on the now.
Maintenance: Is all I committed to in the "important, not urgent" quadrant.
Projects/Learning: Have I got a real boost in creativity and fire to move forward.
Physical: Did I get a good workout for my condition.
Fun/Entertainment: Did I totally escaped reality for a while.
Since the categories are defined by values, they are their own determinators of Effectiveness. And since I always leave time to learn in my day, I often look at what I do and how to do it better.
But for this to work, you need to master having stuff on your list and not commit to it. This way, those things don't bug you and you commit only to the most valued things.
As for a "metric" for the system itself: since I manage my energies during the day, if I find that in this particular time of year, I do more creative things then budgeted, then I simply re-budget :)
P.S: Sorry for the long rant...
Wow, this is a good question!
It had me thinking for about half an hour (which means it has a lot of value for me because it will be effective in furthering my understanding of myself and my system). But still, I'm writing this as I think so I hope you will excuse the lack of conciseness and the length of it. From the bat, I must say that I don't believe that there are "metrics" easily applicable but there are ways to ensure good effectiveness in what you do.
First, I think that effectiveness is directly related to value. If you gain a lot of value from one activity compared to another, then it is more effective for you. The problem is, the type of value is quite different from task to task and from person to person. But there is 2 built in processes in my system that assure that I do the things that have the most value.
One of those is that I limit. I simply limit the amount that I'm willing to do in a day. Let me give you an example and explain the concept. If I give you 10 different cakes (and let's assume you like cake) as choices for desert but you can only choose one. You will, without fail, take the one that will give you the most enjoyment.
On top of that, that value is compared with all the other things you didn't eat. So the idea that value is also derived from the comparison with another thing comes into play. Therefore I always have a couple of choices in my system to make me choose, hence derive value for each thing and pick the one that has the most and I can only do that. All of Mark's systems have this stamp too!
If you doubt the power of limiting yourself, try Twitter. It's a wonderful tool to learn to write concisely and with value. You only have 140 characters to send your thoughts or a message. So I usually start by typing what I want to say and then cut, rephrase, restructure and change the grammar of the text to fit snuggly in those limits.
Ex:
Everybody should go watch the A-Team movie; it's a "must see"!!!
it was so hilarious... I really laughed when the guy tries to jump-start the ambulance with the defibrillator!
Would become something like:
I found "The A-Team" movie hilarious; it's a Must-See...
Watch for the guy trying to jump-start an ambulance with a defibrillator!!!
By the way, my backlog too has a limit so if I want to put something in, I have to do something or throw something out! And if I only have 30 minutes for my emails this day, I will find the most effective way to do them quite fast.
Then, I have most activities divided into categories where I can not only know what type of mindset and energy I'm going to use but also which value I'm shooting for in those activities:
Rest/Relax: Did I spend time really focussing on the now.
Maintenance: Is all I committed to in the "important, not urgent" quadrant.
Projects/Learning: Have I got a real boost in creativity and fire to move forward.
Physical: Did I get a good workout for my condition.
Fun/Entertainment: Did I totally escaped reality for a while.
Since the categories are defined by values, they are their own determinators of Effectiveness. And since I always leave time to learn in my day, I often look at what I do and how to do it better.
But for this to work, you need to master having stuff on your list and not commit to it. This way, those things don't bug you and you commit only to the most valued things.
As for a "metric" for the system itself: since I manage my energies during the day, if I find that in this particular time of year, I do more creative things then budgeted, then I simply re-budget :)
P.S: Sorry for the long rant...
Reply by Seraphim
Erik,
Thanks for the rant! :-) This stuff is really hard to measure. Peter Drucker, who coined the term "knowledge worker", wrote many books on the topic of measuring productivity when there aren't any widgets to count.
For example, see Drucker's book "Management in the 21st Century", or just google "drucker knowledge worker".
Drucker was the first to frame the question, but he didn't get very far in defining real metrics. But I haven't seen anyone else get much farther than he did.
Lately, I've been trying to get myself to think in terms of "ROI" -- Return On Investment.
The Investment is the effort invested, where "effort" is roughly equivalent to "blood, sweat, and tears".
The Return is the positive impact -- am I getting the results I want? It can also be a measure of leverage -- how much "blood, sweat, and tears" am I reducing for other people, or for myself later on.
I am finding it's easiest to figure out a metric when I am dealing with an ongoing activity, rather than a one-off task or project. For example, I spend some time on "get out the vote" efforts, distributing candidate literature, etc.; and helping coordinate other volunteers. I struggle with how to measure our effectiveness, and to decide where we should focus our effort.
Then a friend recommended a book, Lawrence Grey's "How to Win a Local Election", which had the key insight that most activities can be translated directly into votes. For example, a personal contact (door-to-door precinct work) generally translates into 1.5 votes -- you influence the person you contacted, plus some of their relatives and friends, minus a percentage of people who don't like your message. Putting up a sign for a candidate might generate 2 votes. But it can take 10 phone calls to get 1 vote.
This means that my team and I are really a "vote factory". Favorable votes are our widgets. There are other important things we must also do -- like decide which candidates we want to support! -- but the purpose of all the precinct work, signs, and meetings is to generate those votes. Otherwise it's just busywork.
This example has helped me think of ways to measure other things that I do on a regular basis -- any kind of maintenance activity or ongoing project. The trick seems to be to define the desired outcome in measurable units.
The "SMART" goal method is similar on the surface -- "make sure your goals are Measurable". But for me, this is a little different. This process is more iterative, more agile, and less top-down than SMART.
Thanks for the rant! :-) This stuff is really hard to measure. Peter Drucker, who coined the term "knowledge worker", wrote many books on the topic of measuring productivity when there aren't any widgets to count.
For example, see Drucker's book "Management in the 21st Century", or just google "drucker knowledge worker".
Drucker was the first to frame the question, but he didn't get very far in defining real metrics. But I haven't seen anyone else get much farther than he did.
Lately, I've been trying to get myself to think in terms of "ROI" -- Return On Investment.
The Investment is the effort invested, where "effort" is roughly equivalent to "blood, sweat, and tears".
The Return is the positive impact -- am I getting the results I want? It can also be a measure of leverage -- how much "blood, sweat, and tears" am I reducing for other people, or for myself later on.
I am finding it's easiest to figure out a metric when I am dealing with an ongoing activity, rather than a one-off task or project. For example, I spend some time on "get out the vote" efforts, distributing candidate literature, etc.; and helping coordinate other volunteers. I struggle with how to measure our effectiveness, and to decide where we should focus our effort.
Then a friend recommended a book, Lawrence Grey's "How to Win a Local Election", which had the key insight that most activities can be translated directly into votes. For example, a personal contact (door-to-door precinct work) generally translates into 1.5 votes -- you influence the person you contacted, plus some of their relatives and friends, minus a percentage of people who don't like your message. Putting up a sign for a candidate might generate 2 votes. But it can take 10 phone calls to get 1 vote.
This means that my team and I are really a "vote factory". Favorable votes are our widgets. There are other important things we must also do -- like decide which candidates we want to support! -- but the purpose of all the precinct work, signs, and meetings is to generate those votes. Otherwise it's just busywork.
This example has helped me think of ways to measure other things that I do on a regular basis -- any kind of maintenance activity or ongoing project. The trick seems to be to define the desired outcome in measurable units.
The "SMART" goal method is similar on the surface -- "make sure your goals are Measurable". But for me, this is a little different. This process is more iterative, more agile, and less top-down than SMART.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Wow some great ideas are emerging! I agree with Erik that each kind of activity has a different kind of measure.
"Worked on a task 2 hours" is not a measure of productivity, though "Worked this week for 30 minutes" might be a clue why something isn't progressing. "Completed 6 things" doesn't tell you much either. Me, I'm starting to log "work completed". Each task I finish I write in the log. So I will have a list of accomplishments over time.
A Good Day? It's virtually impossible to classify each day as good or bad. Some days are obvious, but... One day is too short to measure productivity. Sometimes you do much work but complete nothing. You can compare one week to another, or one month to another. It's not so much the quantity of things done, but rather a subjective impression of whether one week was better or worse than another. Look at the collection of completed work, and the impact of that work, and decide whether it's good.
Task-Specific Success Measures. For creative work, you could track the amount of time on a project, and grade the work ABCDF. Or count money earned or people's responses.
For routine work, just measure how long it takes. One week you clean the house top to bottom and it takes 4 hours. Next week you clean bottom to top and it takes only 2 hours.
"Worked on a task 2 hours" is not a measure of productivity, though "Worked this week for 30 minutes" might be a clue why something isn't progressing. "Completed 6 things" doesn't tell you much either. Me, I'm starting to log "work completed". Each task I finish I write in the log. So I will have a list of accomplishments over time.
A Good Day? It's virtually impossible to classify each day as good or bad. Some days are obvious, but... One day is too short to measure productivity. Sometimes you do much work but complete nothing. You can compare one week to another, or one month to another. It's not so much the quantity of things done, but rather a subjective impression of whether one week was better or worse than another. Look at the collection of completed work, and the impact of that work, and decide whether it's good.
Task-Specific Success Measures. For creative work, you could track the amount of time on a project, and grade the work ABCDF. Or count money earned or people's responses.
For routine work, just measure how long it takes. One week you clean the house top to bottom and it takes 4 hours. Next week you clean bottom to top and it takes only 2 hours.
Reply by Cricket
Time spent works best for me. Not spending enough time on things (and the corollary of spending too much time on other things) is normally the reason I don't get things done. I tried tracking my focus so I could improve it, but it became another excuse. Rather than spend 30 minutes getting only 15 minutes done, I'd put it off until the (mythical) time I would be able to focus better.
AF is nice because it lets me do anything on the list rather than exactly what's scheduled. It lets me choose the task that best fits my focus and energy at the moment (or convinces me that no task is ideal for the moment, so I may as well roll the dice and pick one).
AF is nice because it lets me do anything on the list rather than exactly what's scheduled. It lets me choose the task that best fits my focus and energy at the moment (or convinces me that no task is ideal for the moment, so I may as well roll the dice and pick one).
Reply by leon
I wonder if it's worth doing some sort of weekly / monthly retrospective that focuses on *completion*?
The *completion* might be tasks / projects / chunks of things that bring a feeling of achievement and satisfaction.
I say this because I believe many of us continue to drive forward incessantly, maybe feeling like we will never do, or be *enough*.
Surely there is value in taking stock and feeling good about what we *have* achieved?
I say 'we' and 'us' but I am really talking about myself here.
The *completion* might be tasks / projects / chunks of things that bring a feeling of achievement and satisfaction.
I say this because I believe many of us continue to drive forward incessantly, maybe feeling like we will never do, or be *enough*.
Surely there is value in taking stock and feeling good about what we *have* achieved?
I say 'we' and 'us' but I am really talking about myself here.
Reply by Erik
@Leon
I think you're right.
That's why I use the kanban method.
I do that very thing in 1 minute at the end of each day ;)
It really has brought back the focus from the backlog to what I'm doing now and what I have done!
I think you're right.
That's why I use the kanban method.
I do that very thing in 1 minute at the end of each day ;)
It really has brought back the focus from the backlog to what I'm doing now and what I have done!
Reply by leon
Hi Erik,
An interesting approach. I suppose I may have experienced something similar when I tried the Pomodoro Technique. Meaning daily feedback on stuff completed.
I wonder if it would be effective to describe say, 1 - 5 year aims / goals in the back of a notebook? From the front of the notebook could be a daily / weekly / monthly retrospective of work completed.
Gradually it may be possible to see the gap closing between the retrospective reviews and the longer term aims / goals.
This in some ways is similar to Gerry's Do It methodology in that the emphasis is sort of on closing resources gaps whilst also generating self feedback on work completed.
An interesting approach. I suppose I may have experienced something similar when I tried the Pomodoro Technique. Meaning daily feedback on stuff completed.
I wonder if it would be effective to describe say, 1 - 5 year aims / goals in the back of a notebook? From the front of the notebook could be a daily / weekly / monthly retrospective of work completed.
Gradually it may be possible to see the gap closing between the retrospective reviews and the longer term aims / goals.
This in some ways is similar to Gerry's Do It methodology in that the emphasis is sort of on closing resources gaps whilst also generating self feedback on work completed.
Reply by Erik
@Leon
The thing I find most sad about lists is this. All day, you go through your stuff and strike things out. It's a good feeling but something that doesn't last so you need to strike something else asap to feel engaged. And at the end of the day, you are left with... Emptiness!
You strike through your stuff and what's left is what you didn't do. So your focussing on the backlog. Now even if you write what you achieved as goals, it's not representative of the effort you put into it. So in essence you strike a bunch of tasks to earn the right to write one goal as accomplished. They are not even related.
You can't know the satisfaction of seeing a task going from "to do", transform into "doing" and finally get to "done" unless you actually try it. You don't rewrite it; it's just the same thing but it's nature changes. What your left at the end of the day is a WALL of stuff you've achieved!!! It's just amazing. Your effectively and literally "building" your day instead of "destroying" your backlog...
It's hard to explain but that's my view on it. That said I do believe that if you are to use lists, then yeah, definitely find a way to see what you accomplished and take that focus out of the "I haven't done this yet..." to the "Wow, look what I did today!"
The thing I find most sad about lists is this. All day, you go through your stuff and strike things out. It's a good feeling but something that doesn't last so you need to strike something else asap to feel engaged. And at the end of the day, you are left with... Emptiness!
You strike through your stuff and what's left is what you didn't do. So your focussing on the backlog. Now even if you write what you achieved as goals, it's not representative of the effort you put into it. So in essence you strike a bunch of tasks to earn the right to write one goal as accomplished. They are not even related.
You can't know the satisfaction of seeing a task going from "to do", transform into "doing" and finally get to "done" unless you actually try it. You don't rewrite it; it's just the same thing but it's nature changes. What your left at the end of the day is a WALL of stuff you've achieved!!! It's just amazing. Your effectively and literally "building" your day instead of "destroying" your backlog...
It's hard to explain but that's my view on it. That said I do believe that if you are to use lists, then yeah, definitely find a way to see what you accomplished and take that focus out of the "I haven't done this yet..." to the "Wow, look what I did today!"
Reply by Alan Baljeu
In line with Erik's comments, how about highlighting actioned items instead of crossing them?
Second idea: a journal that starts with goals, and daily records what progress you've made. (also record plans you make to do even better?)
As for AF and DWM, the goal is to complete that first page. Take note of each page you finish as success.
Second idea: a journal that starts with goals, and daily records what progress you've made. (also record plans you make to do even better?)
As for AF and DWM, the goal is to complete that first page. Take note of each page you finish as success.
Reply by Erin
The evidence of a productive day for me is one that is balanced and a real treat is getting something off the backlog. If I fixate on getting one thing done, pushing way to much, I don't feel I had a good day, and the "problem" thing is still there the next day.
@Alan: your highlighting idea reminds me when I worked in a place that had a large chart on the wall of the week's worth work for our department. When the jobs were completed they were highlighted in blue rather than crossed off. When the whole week was filled with blue we all felt a sense of accomplishment. And if they weren't all done we scrambled to get the last few to blue.
@Alan: your highlighting idea reminds me when I worked in a place that had a large chart on the wall of the week's worth work for our department. When the jobs were completed they were highlighted in blue rather than crossed off. When the whole week was filled with blue we all felt a sense of accomplishment. And if they weren't all done we scrambled to get the last few to blue.
Reply by Roger J
@Erin@Alan: Harking back to the very first AF (1?) at the end of 2008, I recall highlighting all completed tasks in green, deferred (due mainly to context in my travelling work/lifestyle) in orange and dismissed or LTBW in pink.
I still like crossing the task through, but one can still highlight to get the effect, I think I used a line and green back in AF1.
Maybe I'll try this again.
I still like crossing the task through, but one can still highlight to get the effect, I think I used a line and green back in AF1.
Maybe I'll try this again.
Reply by leon
@Erik, thank you for your insightful comments, I'll check out your Sources website again soon.
Highlighting completed tasks sounds like a good idea. Maybe it's actually better to cross out the rejected / dismissed items. However it may then may be difficult to have them on review as such.
I suppose a potential disadvantage is that a highlighter will be needed more of the time?
Maybe a box and a tick would work, but not be as easy to spot?
Highlighting completed tasks sounds like a good idea. Maybe it's actually better to cross out the rejected / dismissed items. However it may then may be difficult to have them on review as such.
I suppose a potential disadvantage is that a highlighter will be needed more of the time?
Maybe a box and a tick would work, but not be as easy to spot?
Reply by Seraphim
Erik wrote:
<<>>
This is really appealing to me. Often I feel at the end of a 14-hour day that I'm not really sure what I did all that time, though I'm exhausted and feel like I "got a lot done". I can go back and look at my Completed Tasks in Outlook, and that gives me a rough idea. But the real test for me is whether I can explain it to my wife when she asks why this or that project still isn't finished. She's not very impressed by "little and often". :-) She (rightly!!) wants to see ***results that matter***.
And so do I.
Hmm, I guess I finally need to watch Erik's videos. I've been avidly reading his comments, but still haven't grok'd what his ideas are really all about. Good thing I don't have any more meetings today...
<<
This is really appealing to me. Often I feel at the end of a 14-hour day that I'm not really sure what I did all that time, though I'm exhausted and feel like I "got a lot done". I can go back and look at my Completed Tasks in Outlook, and that gives me a rough idea. But the real test for me is whether I can explain it to my wife when she asks why this or that project still isn't finished. She's not very impressed by "little and often". :-) She (rightly!!) wants to see ***results that matter***.
And so do I.
Hmm, I guess I finally need to watch Erik's videos. I've been avidly reading his comments, but still haven't grok'd what his ideas are really all about. Good thing I don't have any more meetings today...
Reply by MartyH
I have to provide a weekly report to my boss. It usually includes issues I've struggled with (and therefore need assistance or top cover) as well as accomplishments.
As I start with the previous report and delete completed items, I am starting with a list of outstanding tasks or problems which sets the stage for the next week. Any changes get made in blue as the week goes on, so it show progress on items as well as new items either completed or identified. (Identifying an issue is progress as well for me.) The more blue, the better. It is completely separate from my DWM list, but helps to keep me focused on items that are important.
So this report that seemed like a waste of time when I first started doing it, can be a motivator. If I've been good about updating it daily and it doesn't show much progress, it motivates me to work harder and produce real progress during the remainder of the week. When little is accomplished for the whole week, it serves as motivation for the following week.
While it doesn't track productivity from a statistical standpoint, it does clearly show progress (or lack thereof when things hang around in the report without it). I'm forced to really look at whether an item hanging around is something that will get done or not and goes beyond the little and often that lets it remain on my DWM list. I am overloaded, so there are always choices about what isn't going to get done. Sometimes no good choices remain and my boss sees that about the same time I do. That allows for him to provide assistance for those things he wants done because he can see what won't get done without it.
As I start with the previous report and delete completed items, I am starting with a list of outstanding tasks or problems which sets the stage for the next week. Any changes get made in blue as the week goes on, so it show progress on items as well as new items either completed or identified. (Identifying an issue is progress as well for me.) The more blue, the better. It is completely separate from my DWM list, but helps to keep me focused on items that are important.
So this report that seemed like a waste of time when I first started doing it, can be a motivator. If I've been good about updating it daily and it doesn't show much progress, it motivates me to work harder and produce real progress during the remainder of the week. When little is accomplished for the whole week, it serves as motivation for the following week.
While it doesn't track productivity from a statistical standpoint, it does clearly show progress (or lack thereof when things hang around in the report without it). I'm forced to really look at whether an item hanging around is something that will get done or not and goes beyond the little and often that lets it remain on my DWM list. I am overloaded, so there are always choices about what isn't going to get done. Sometimes no good choices remain and my boss sees that about the same time I do. That allows for him to provide assistance for those things he wants done because he can see what won't get done without it.
Reply by Erik
@Seraphim
I'm flattered!
If I have any advice about viewing the videos:
Try to leave some time between them to let things sink in...
I'm flattered!
If I have any advice about viewing the videos:
Try to leave some time between them to let things sink in...
Reply by Seraphim
Hi Erik -- Great video. I watched the main "My System" video (58 minutes - http://www.eriklorrain.com/Sources/iVideoBlog/Entries/2010/7/20_My_System.html ). You have an incredible number of insights and creative ideas, all integrated into a beautiful whole.
It's also very clear that you are a teacher -- so many excellent illustrations, like the tree, with maintenance as the roots and project work producing the fruits.
I really enjoyed it, and learned a lot! I will definitely be trying to work many of these ideas into my own self-management. Thanks very much!!
It's also very clear that you are a teacher -- so many excellent illustrations, like the tree, with maintenance as the roots and project work producing the fruits.
I really enjoyed it, and learned a lot! I will definitely be trying to work many of these ideas into my own self-management. Thanks very much!!
Reply by Erik
You are more then welcome :)
Thanks for the comment!
As we say here in Japan: お疲れさまでした!(Otsukare-sama deshita!)
Which roughly means, congratulations on the hard work...
For watching this video is not a small feat.
Good things come in small packages but sometimes
it's worth to give something the time it deserves ;)
Thanks for the comment!
As we say here in Japan: お疲れさまでした!(Otsukare-sama deshita!)
Which roughly means, congratulations on the hard work...
For watching this video is not a small feat.
Good things come in small packages but sometimes
it's worth to give something the time it deserves ;)